Current Events
![]() ![]()
Federal Court Saya That the Michigan High School Athletic Association Discriminates Against Female Athletes
![]()
Federal Appeals Court Rules State Athletic Assoc. Discriminates Against Female Athletes
July 27, 2004 National Women's Law Center Washington, DC The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals today ruled that the Michigan High School Athletic Association (MHSAA) discriminates against female high school athletes in Michigan by scheduling only their sports in nontraditional and less advantageous seasons, in violation of the United States Constitution. The National Womens Law Center (NWLC), which is of counsel in the class action law suit MHSAA v. Communities for Equity (CFE), praised the decision and urged MHSAA to bring its scheduling of girls sports into compliance with the law. The district court, and now the court of appeals, has ruled that MHSAAs scheduling of girls sports violates the law, said Neena Chaudhry, NWLC senior counsel. MHSAA must stop asking Michigan high school girls to get in line behind the boys and instead focus on ensuring that girls have the athletic opportunities they deserve. In December 2001, the federal district court in Grand Rapids ruled that MHSAAs scheduling of girls sports violates the Constitutions Equal Protection Clause and federal and state laws. MHSAA schedules six high school girls sports, but no boys sports, in nontraditional and disadvantageous seasons. As a result, girls are harmed in ways that boys are not, including: limited opportunities for athletic scholarships and opportunities to play college sports; limited opportunities to play in club or Olympic Development Programs; and missed opportunities for awards and recognition, such as All-American teams. One example of MHSAAs backwards scheduling is that while basketball is traditionally played in the winter and volleyball is played in the fall, in Michigan girls have to play basketball in the fall and volleyball in the winter. The courts opinion today cited one of MHSAAs own publications as evidence that girls were treated differently than boys. In its 1990 Bulletin, MHSAAs Executive Director explains, Boys sports were in [MHSAA member] schools first and girls sports, which came later, were fitted around the pre-existing boys program. It is past time that Michigan girls get the equal opportunities they deserve, said Chaudhry. MHSAA should put into place the compliance plan already approved by the district court without delay. |