Stories and Grievances: Special Education
A Parent's Guide To Response to Intervention (RTI) by Susan Bruce
Wrightslaw: When IDEA was reauthorized in 2004 some new buzz words emerged. One term is Response to Intervention (RTI). Although response to intervention is not actually new, it is very new to IDEA, parents, and to many school districts. RTI in IDEA and “scientifically research based instruction” in IDEA and NCLB emphasize the quality of instruction ALL children receive. NCLB and IDEA raise the bar in education by attempting to ensure that ALL children receive high quality instruction. The purpose of RTI is to catch struggling children early, provide appropriate instruction, and prevent the need to refer the child for special education. This concept offers hope and fear in advocates and parents.
A Parent's Guide to Response to Intervention (RTI)
by Susan Bruce, Regional Education Coordinator
When IDEA was reauthorized in 2004 some new buzz words emerged. One term is Response to Intervention (RTI). Although response to intervention is not actually new, it is very new to IDEA, parents, and to many school districts.
RTI in IDEA and “scientifically research based instruction” in IDEA and NCLB emphasize the quality of instruction ALL children receive. NCLB and IDEA raise the bar in education by attempting to ensure that ALL children receive high quality instruction. The purpose of RTI is to catch struggling children early, provide appropriate instruction, and prevent the need to refer the child for special education. This concept offers hope and fear in advocates and parents.
In an attempt by the US Department of Education to eliminate the wall that separates regular and special education, school districts may use 15% of IDEA funding for early intervention services in regular education - RTI.
RTI and Hope for Better Instruction
RTI offers hope that all children will receive better and more adequate instruction in math and reading. RTI provides a new and different way to identify students with specific learning disabilities.
But, there are important issues that parents need to be aware of. If we, as parents, are not educated on the RTI process and what IDEA requires, our schools may fail to identify some children who do have specific learning disabilities.
I concur with the experts who say that many children have not received the type of instruction they need to be successful. The regular education core curriculum often leaves out one or more of the five essential components required for effective reading instruction by the National Reading Panel. When used as intended, RTI should eliminate this problem.
What is RTI?
RTI is a tiered process of instruction that allows schools to identify struggling students early and provide appropriate instructional interventions. Early intervention means more chances for success and less need for special education services. RTI would also address the needs of children who previously did not qualify for special education.
RTI Should be a School Wide Model
Although, a schools model may look different, there are several essential and necessary components that parents need be aware of:
Scientifically Research Based Instruction - All children should receive research based reading instruction in the general education classroom.
School Wide Screening - Schools should screen all children early to determine if they are “at risk.”
Continuous Progress Monitoring - Schools should monitor the progress of all “at risk” children to determine if they are benefiting from instruction.
Fidelity - Schools must use any program or curriculum correctly and as intended.
Procedural Safeguards - Schools must ensure parents are aware of their rights.
Tiers in RTI
RTI is a delivered to students in tiers or levels. There is much discussion about how many tiers should be in RTI models. The three-tiered model is the most common. This means there are different levels of intervention, based on the needs of the student. The level of intervention increases in intensity if a child does not respond to instruction.
IDEA does not specify how many tiers an RTI model must contain. IDEA does not specify how long a child must remain in one tier before moving to the next level. The US Department of Education left this to the states to determine.
What RTI is NOT
Special seating in classroom
“More of the same” general classroom instruction
What IDEA Says about RTI and SLD
Section 300.307 of the federal Special Education Regulations says that states must adopt criteria for determining whether a child has a specific learning disability. States must not require the use of a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement model. States must permit the use of a process based on the child's response to scientific, research-based intervention.
When IDEA was reauthorized in 2004, RTI was added in an attempt to bring IDEA in line with NCLB and Reading First. In the Commentary to the Regulations, US DOE acknowledged that identification “models that incorporate RTI represent a shift in special education toward goals of better achievement and improved behavioral outcomes for children with specific learning disability (SLD).”
Concerns about the RTI Process
I agree with the experts who say that many children are identified with specific learning disabilities because they do not receive adequate instruction in reading and math. In other words, these children are not making sufficient progress because they receive poor instruction, not because they have a learning disability.
I also believe some children have specific learning disabilities.
My fear is that school districts may use RTI to delay, or worse, to not evaluate children who are suspected of having specific learning disabilities.
In the Commentary to the federal special education regulations, many people expressed these same concerns. Because of these comments, and to ensure that parents are notified of their right to request an evaluation at any time, the US Department of Education added the following to the federal regulation Section 300.311 (Commentary in the Federal Register at p. 46658):
(a) For a child suspected of having a specific learning disability, the documentation of the determination of eligibility, as required in 300.306(a)(2), must contain a statement of--
(7) If the child has participated in a process that assesses the child’s response to scientific, research-based intervention—
(i) The instructional strategies used and the student-centered data collected; and
(ii) The documentation that the child’s parents were notified about—
(A) The State’s policies regarding the amount and nature of student performance data that would be collected and the general education services that would be provided;
(B) Strategies for increasing the child’s rate of learning; and
(C) The parents’ right to request an evaluation.
(b) Each group member must certify in writing whether the report reflects the member’s conclusion. If it does not reflect the member’s conclusion, the group member must submit a separate statement presenting the member’s conclusions.
What Does RTI Mean for our Kids?
States must put into place criteria for determining whether or not a child has a Specific Learning Disability (SLD).
All children should receive appropriate and adequate instruction in the regular education classroom before being referred to special education.
The RTI process does not replace the need for a comprehensive evaluation.
When a child is participating in an RTI model, parents must be notified of the instructional strategies used, performance data collected, and the general education services that will be provided.
Parent’s have the right to request a comprehensive evaluation at any time during the RTI process.
Schools must promptly request parental consent to evaluate when a child suspected of having an SLD has not made progress when provided with appropriate instruction.
Questions for Parents and Educators
The federal regulations specify that “States must permit the use of a process based on the child's response to scientific, research-based intervention.” This is not a question of “if” a school district will be required to use RTI, but when. The Commentary to the federal regulations (p.46646-46647) describes the Essential Components of Reading Instruction and references what the ESEA (NCLB) says about appropriate reading instruction including: Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Vocabulary Development, Reading Fluency, Reading Comprehension Skills.
When should a parent be notified of their right to request an evaluation?
In general, when the child moves from a tier 1 general education (class wide intervention) to a tier 2 (more targeted small group interventions), parents should be informed about what is happening and their rights.
Parents should be advised that their child is not making expected academic progress, the services that will be provided and strategies used to increase their child's progress, and other options that are available to them i.e., the right to request an evaluation under IDEA at any time. (NICHCY's "Building the Legacy Training Curriculum on the IDEA 2004", Module 6 - Early Intervening Services and Response to Intervention.)
Questions Parents Should Ask about RTI
There are specific questions parents should ask to ensure that their child will be accurately identified, and is receiving appropriate instruction to begin with.
How many tiers are included the RTI model?
How long will my child remain in a tier before moving to the next tier?
What scientifically research based form of instruction will the teacher use?
What documentation demonstrates the effectiveness of the program?
What education journal documents this form of instruction as “peer reviewed”?
Does the reading program include the elements defined as "essential components of an effective reading program" set forth by the National Reading Panel?
How often will the school monitor my child's progress?
What type of progress monitoring will the school use?
When will the school report the progress monitoring results to us, the parents, and how often?
Will the type of progress monitoring used show how the child is progressing when compared to his peers?
What rate of progress should we parents expect?
At what point will the school refer our child for an evaluation due to lack of response to instruction?
What do your state regulations say about the RTI process?
The Bottom Line
RTI, if used as intended, will be a significant advance in special education. If used incorrectly, RTI will prevent students who have true learning disabilities from receiving the specialized instruction they need.
As with any special educational issue that affects our children, we parents must become experts on RTI. We must educate ourselves, ask questions, and document what we are told.
Meet Susan Bruce
Susan is the mother of three children with learning disabilities.
After spending years researching and learning about IDEA and about her children's disabilities, Susan has spent the last two years applying what she learned. Susan is now a "force to be reckoned with" when advocating for children with disabilities.
Read Susan's Success Story about charting her children's test scores and what happened as a result of this in From Victim to a Mighty Force: The Numbers Do Not Lie.
Susan is currently working for her state Parent and Training Information Center. She is the Region 3 Regional Education Coordinator for PRO*Parents of South Carolina, Inc.